Make Money

Paid Surveys

Gig Jobs

Passive Income

Best Place to Sell Beanie Babies: A List of 10 Platforms

DollarBreak is reader-supported, when you sign up through links on this post, we may receive compensation. Disclosure.

10 Places to Sell Beanie Babies

Best Place to Sell Beanie BabiesSelling Fee
Facebook Marketplace0%
eBayAround 12.55%
Etsy5%
Craigslist0%
Mercari10%
VarageSale0%
PlushCollector0%
Sell4ValuePays $0.40 per item
Sell2BBNovelties0%
Local Flea MarketsFees may apply

Facebook Marketplace


Facebook Marketplace Summary

  • Buyer and seller accountability as you need a Facebook account
  • Built in messaging system to keep on top of queries
  • Access to a massive marketplace
  • Ratings system maintains honesty

Facebook Marketplace is one of the places you can sell Beanie Babies. With nearly 3 billion users, there’s a great chance you’ll find a collector on this platform. 

Selling on Facebook takes several easy steps if you already have an account there. After signing in to your account, just click on the Marketplace icon on the sidebar and choose “Create New Listing.” 

From there, you can provide details on your Beanie Babies and upload as many photos as you can. This helps potential buyers tell right away if what you’re selling is exactly what they’re looking for. 

What’s great about using Facebook Marketplace is that you don’t have to pay listing fees. There’s also a built-in messaging platform, Facebook Messenger, that helps connect you with buyers. 

Finally, a Facebook account is necessary to use the Marketplace. You can easily check if your buyers are legit. 

eBay


eBay Summary

  • High user traffic – over 187 million users
  • No listing fees for small scale sellers
  • Promote your listing from as little as 1%
  • Quick processing time for payouts

eBay is another platform where you can likely look for Beanie Babies collectors as it has more than 187 million active users globally. You can also enjoy zero listing fees if you’re creating less than 250 different listings. 

Additionally, the platform offers a minimal cost, around 1% of your asking price, to promote your listing. This way, you can reach more potential buyers for your Beanie Babies. 

Just note that every time your item sells, eBay charges seller fees of around 12.55% of the final sale price. Despite these fees, eBay is still preferable as it offers a secured mode of payment.

After buyers pay, you’ll receive the funds to your eBay account within two days. From there, you can cash out to PayPal or withdraw your funds to your bank account. 

Mercari


Mercari Summary

  • Listing your items on the platform is free
  • Mercari has a low commission of 10% on every item you sell
  • Mercari provides a prepaid shipping label with insurance worth up to $200
  • You’ll get paid quickly – within 3 days after the buyer has received your item

Mercari is an eCommerce platform initially launched in Japan in 2013. Since its expansion to the United States, it has also become one of the places people buy and sell stuff online. 

Just upload up to 12 photos of your item and add some details. Make sure to enable the app notification on your phone. Once a buyer purchases your Beanie Baby, you’ll get a notification.

From there, you’ll need to pack and ship the item within three days. Mercari handles the payment processing so you don’t need to deal with that. After fulfilling the order, Mercari will credit the payment to your account. 

What’s good about Mercari is that you can list for free. However, they charge a payment processing fee of 2.9%, plus $0.30. There’s also a 10% commission they take from your sales.

Etsy


Etsy Summary

  • Easy to set up & maintain your store
  • 45+ million active Etsy buyers
  • List your first item for just $0.20
  • Automatic deposits and secure transactions

If you have several Beanie Babies to sell and think of setting up an online store, make sure to check out Etsy. This eCommerce website offers a free way of setting up your online store. You can customize everything to reflect your brand. 

Adding products to your Etsy store is free but to publish your product listings, it charges $0.20 per product. This allows Etsy to keep your listing active for four months.

Besides listing, Etsy also charges 5% of the total sales amount as a transaction fee. On top of that, there’ll be a processing fee of 3% plus $0.25 every time you receive an order. 

Considering the costs when selling Beanie Babies, make sure to market your Etsy online store to maximize your earnings. 

Craigslist


Craigslist Summary

  • Posts are anonymous
  • Quick and easy listing in a matter of minutes
  • Little to no seller fees, most auctions are free
  • Sell within your local area

Craigslist is another platform where you can sell Beanie Babies to collectors. This platform is incredibly easy to use, letting you create a listing in 10 minutes. 

What’s also good with Craigslist is that you can create posts in your locality. You can also choose a city to share your listing with. This option works well if you’re looking to sell to nearby collectors and prefer to transact with them in person.

Just note that Craigslist works as local classifieds. Considering that, potential buyers may not only be limited to collectors. Sharing your contact details on your listing can also be risky. 

As a best practice, choose a phone number you’ll exclusively use to contact potential buyers. Also, use the Craigslist provided email, instead of your personal email, for buyers to contact you.  

VarageSale


VarageSale is an online marketplace where you can sell your Beanie Babies. Using its website or app, you can create an account and link your Facebook profile to verify your identity. Once done, you can create a listing for your items.

Posting here is completely free. When your Beanie Babies get a potential buyer, you’ll receive a notification. From there, you can chat with them to set up a meeting. 

After finalizing the transaction, make sure to set your listing to “Reserve.” What’s next is to meet your buyer, complete the sale, and receive your payment. Don’t forget to mark your Beanie Babies sold and leave your customer a review.

PlushCollector


Just looking at its name, PlushCollector is certainly one of the places you can sell Beanie Babies online. Unlike other platforms where you need to create a listing, PlushCollector will buy your Beanie Babies. 

This way, you can skip dealing with buyers and quickly sell your items. Plus, PlushCollector will cover shipping for orders above $25. 

Here’s how to sell your beanie babies with PlushCollector:

  • Visit the PlushCollector website.
  • Search for Beanie Babies you’ll sell.
  • Click on “Add to Quote” under your Beanie Babies photo on the website. Doing this adds your Beanie Babies to your Request A Quote form. 
  • After sending your request order form, a PlushCollector sales associate will contact you within 24 hours. 
  • They’ll provide you with the steps to ship your Beanie Babies. 

PlushCollector will check the condition and authenticity of your items and pay you within one week. 

Sell4Value


Sell4Value is another company that buys Beanie Babies. It works similarly to PlushCollector since you can ship your Beanie Babies when selling to them. 

However, this platform offers an option where you can set an appointment at their store and bring your beanies. For both options, Sell4Value pays $0.40 per item. If you’re sending more than 99 Beanie Babies, Sell4Value will also cover shipping fees. 

Once they receive your items, Sell4Value will check their condition and send a check payment within one to three business days. 

Sell2BBNovelties


Beanie Babies are among the items you can sell to Sell2BBNovelties. This platform works like Sell4Value and PlushCollector, letting you ship your Beanies for cash.  

Unlike other platforms where you need to manually search, Sell2BBNovelties has a Lookup Library. With this, you can search your Beanie Babies using their barcode and add them to your sell order. 

This way, it’s easy to add items to your sell order. Just make sure that your Beanie Babies are in mint condition, as Sell2BBNovelties reject those that aren’t. Finally, you can ship for free if your sell order reaches $30 or more. 

Local Flea Markets


Besides doing it online, you can also sell Beanie Babies to local flea markets. This option works ideally if you have other items, besides Beanie Babies, to sell. You can also opt for flea markets if you’re letting go of a large Beanie Babies collection. 

What’s good about selling on local flea markets is that you can sell your plushies for higher prices. 

Also, setting up a table at a local flea market allows you to encourage non-collectors to start collecting Beanie Babies.  If you’re selling an entire collection, this can be highly advantageous. 

How Much Can You Get for Your Beanie Baby?


How much you can get for your Beanie Baby depends on many factors, including:

  • Generation
  • Rarity
  • Condition
  • Hang Tags
  • Tush Tags
  • Certificate of Authenticity

It also depends on where you’re selling. For example, PlushCollector buys Beanie Babies for at least $0.13, with some priced at $1.50. Meanwhile, Sell4Value buys them for $0.40 each.

At Etsy, retired Beanie Babies cost around $2.95 and can get up to $30. Rare Beanie Babies, like Hope Bear and Erin the Bear, can get up to $15,000.


Photo of author

Kate Starr

Dollarbreak

About the author:

The content on dollarbreak.com is for informational and educational purposes only and cannot replace any professional financial advice.
Conduct your own research and seek the advice of a licensed financial advisor. Please read the full Terms of use and Privacy Policy.

Contents