Make Money

Paid Surveys

Gig Jobs

Passive Income

Worthy Review 2024 – Is Worthy a Good Place to Sell a Diamond?

DollarBreak is reader-supported, when you sign up through links on this post, we may receive compensation. Disclosure.

We test different ways to make money online weekly and provide real-user reviews so you can decide whether each platform is right for you to earn side money. So far, we have reviewed 600+ platforms and websites. Methodology.

Worthy Review

worthy logo

If you have a designer or diamond jewelry, or a branded watch you no longer need and want to sell for extra money, Worthy is worth it. The platform enables you to sell your precious jewelry at an auction and get the most money for your items. For example, 18K gold stud earrings were recently sold for $1,125 through the platform.

Safe & Legit

Seller Fees

Earning Potential

Payout Process

Pros

  • Sell fine jewelry on auction
  • Seamless selling process
  • Quick payments
  • Set your own prices

Cons

  • No guarantee of successful auctions
  • Auction offers may be lower than set price

Jump to: Full Review

Best Places to Sell Gold and Jewelry

Cash for Gold USA

Cash for Gold USA logo

Cash for Gold USA will buy gold of any karat from 8k to 24k, and in any form, even scrap

Quick processing time for quotes – within 24 hours once gold is received

Free FedEx shipping label insured up to $5000 for you to send your gold

Express Gold Cash

Express Gold Cash logo

Sell any jewelry – bracelets, rings, necklaces, watches, earrings, coins, platinum

Free, overnight shipping for your items with insurance for up to $5,000

Accept the offer, and receive your payment within 24 hours or get a free return

Cash for Diamonds

Cash for Diamonds logo

Get a free appraisal kit by filling out the form – send diamonds with free, tracked shipping

Payments are typically processed within 24 hours after you accept offer

If you don’t like the offer – Diamonds will be returned free of charge

What is Worthy?


Worthy was founded in 2014 by investment banker Ben De-Kalo in New York City, U.S. It’s a jewelry selling partner that is dedicated to providing sellers with the ultimate selling experience.

The platform brings together buyers and sellers with its luxury online auction marketplace. 

With Worthy, you can sell your diamond and designer jewelry, and branded watches. Worthy allows you to set the reserve price for your items and will create the auction listing for you. 

Once your item sells, Worthy will send you your payment.

How Much Can You Earn With Worthy?


How much you earn on Worthy depends on how many items you are, what price you set them for, and how much you make on the auction. With Worthy, you get to determine the price for your items.

The table below shows some of the recently sold jewelry through the Worthy platform:

Sold forJewelryStyleMetal TypeMetal Weight
$1,4112x ring setBridal Set18K Gold7.8 g.
$5,556Collar necklaceCollar14K Gold20.85 g.
$1,125EarringsStud18K Gold1.11 g.

Worthy Reviews: Is Worthy Legit?


Worthy has a 4.8-star rating on Trustpilot, a 4.7-star rating on SiteJabber, and a 4.5-star rating on BBB.

Review SiteReview Score
Trustpilot4.8
SiteJabber4.7
BBB4.5

Customers have praised Worthy for giving prompt responses to questions, providing fair prices, and providing customers with a seamless selling process.

Customers have complained about receiving low prices on their auctioned items, not getting their jewelry returned in a timely manner, and providing customers with unsuccessful auctions.

Who Is Worthy Best for?


Worthy is best for people who have designer and diamond jewelry or branded watches they are looking to sell for extra money. If you have jewelry pieces in good condition and no longer use them, you can auction them on Worthy.

What Can You Sell With Worthy?


With Worthy, you can sell your used designer or diamond jewelry, as well as branded watches online. You can easily earn money online by selling your jewelry with Worthy.

Worthy Benefits: What Does Worthy Offer?


Earn Money Online

With Worthy, you can easily earn money online by selling your jewelry or watch for auction. After shipping your item in, the rest of the process is entirely online, making selling your items seamless and straightforward.

Set Your Prices

You get to set the prices for your items on Worthy. You are entirely in charge of how much you list your items up for auction online.

Simple Auction Process

Worthy takes care of preparing, cleaning, and photographing your items for auction and creating the auction listing. All you have to do is ship your item in, free of charge, and set the item’s price.

Worthy Fees: How Much Does It Cost to Use Worthy?


Winning BidFee
Up to $5,00018%
$5,001-$15,00014%
$15,001-$30,00012%
$30,001+10%

Worthy Requirements


To get started with Worthy, you will need to select the jewelry type and choose the selections that describe your jewelry. Once you do, you will fill out your basic information and create an account. Then, you can start using Worthy and ship your item out.

Worthy Payout Terms and Options


Worthy offers various ways to receive your payment:

  • PayPal
  • Wire transfer
  • Check

The payment will be processed 1-5 days following your successful auction. If the payment is over $5,000, PayPal is not available.

What Are the Worthy Pros & Cons?


Worthy Pros

  • Sell fine jewelry at auction
  • Seamless selling process
  • Quick payments
  • Set your own prices    

Worthy Cons

  • No guarantee of successful auctions
  • Auction offers may be lower than the set price

How Good Is the Worthy Support?


Worthy has a large and categorized FAQ page that has various different answers to the most commonly asked questions. You can also contact Worthy by filling out the contact form on their homepage or calling them at 1-888-222-0208.

Worthy Review Verdict: Is Worthy Worth It?


If you have a designer or diamond jewelry, or a branded watch you no longer need and want to sell for extra money, Worthy is worth it. Worthy is a great way to easily make extra money with fine jewelry you want to sell.

The platform enables you to sell your precious jewelry at an auction and get the most money for your items. For example, 18K gold stud earrings were recently sold for $1,125 through the platform. 

Note that Worthy charges you a service fee of 10%-18% for using the platform and all its benefits.

How to Sign Up With Worthy?


To sign up with Worthy, simply select the selections that best describe your jewelry on the signup page. Then, enter your basic details including your name, email, and address to sign up for an account. Once you sign up for an account, you can send your jewelry to Worthy and wait for it to be auctioned.

Sites Like Worthy


CompanyWorthyCash for Gold USADecluttrSwappa
Logo worthy logo cashforgoldusa logo decluttr logo swappa logo
Pricing10%-18%No feesNo feesNo fees
ShippingFreeFreeFreeFree
Best forDesigner jewelryGold jewelryUsed electronicsGently used tech

Worthy vs. Cash for Gold USA


Cash for Gold USA Summary

  • Free shipping and $5000 insurance
  • Quick 24 hour processing time for quotes
  • Earn up to 3 times than elsewhere
  • Sell all sorts of gold, even scrap gold

Like Worthy, Cash for Gold USA is a great platform to sell your precious jewelry. However, compared to Worthy, Cash for Gold USA is best for selling gold items. Plus, since it buys items from you directly, it doesn’t charge any commission and provides a free shipping label for you to send your gold items.

It’s noteworthy that in addition to gold jewelry, Cash for Gold USA also accepts other gold products like coins and scrap or broken gold.

Other Sites Like Worthy


Worthy FAQ


What Is Worthy?

Worthy’s mission is to bring the fairest market value for your valuable items while providing stellar customer service. 

There are over 1,000 professional buyers looking to purchase luxury jewelry, including diamond and designer jewelry, and branded watches.

What types of jewelry do you accept?

Worthy accepts diamond jewelry, designer jewelry, and branded watches.

Can I back out at any time?

Prior to the auction, there is no obligation of any kind. You will work with an auction manager to set a reserve price during the preparation process. If the highest bid meets or exceeds your reserve price, you are committed to selling the piece. If the highest bid does not meet or exceed the reserve price you chose, you can opt to have the piece shipped back to you free of charge.

How long does it take to sell with Worthy?

The process typically takes 10-14 business days from the time your jewelry arrives at Worthy headquarters to getting paid.

What if my piece isn’t in perfect condition?

You can sell imperfect jewelry as they are appraised based on their weight and quality. They can still be sold if they are broken or incomplete. Watches must be in proper working condition in order to sell.

Can I visit Worthy’s offices?

Yes, you can certainly make an appointment at their New York City office by calling them at 1 (888) 222-0208.

Photo of author

Kate Starr

Dollarbreak

About the author:

The content on dollarbreak.com is for informational and educational purposes only and cannot replace any professional financial advice.
Conduct your own research and seek the advice of a licensed financial advisor. Please read the full Terms of use and Privacy Policy.

Contents