Which Payment Type Can Help You Stick to a Budget?

DollarBreak is reader-supported with the goal to become the ultimate practical resource for making money online. When you sign up or buy through links on this post, we may receive compensation. Disclosure.

Best Money Saving Apps


Tally logo

Organize different credit cards in one place

Receive one monthly credit card bill

Settles your payments 2 days before your due date


Rakuten logo

Up to 40% cash-back for your regular purchases

Close to 2500 participating retailers available

Get $25 once your friend spends at least $25 using Rakuten


Truebill logo

The app is free to download. No Savings, no Commissions

Can save on average $96 per year. Has 85% success rate

Tracks your balance for overdrafts and notifies of upcoming bills

What Do People Spend Their Money On?

One of the biggest problems that you may have when budgeting is not knowing where your money goes. Without understanding your outgoings versus your incomings, it will be impossible to set a budget. So, what are the main expenditures of the average American?


According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the average American spends 33% of their income on housing. This makes it the largest area of expenditure totaling an average of $20,091 per year. Housing expenditure includes rent, mortgage interest, interest on home equity loans, property taxes, property insurance, and maintenance and repairs.


Transportation accounts for an average of 13% of Americans’ income, which in 2018 equaled $9,761. This includes things like public transport passes, gasoline prices and vehicle purchases. According to Experian, the average American household owns 2.28 cars, with personal vehicles taking up a large portion of these transportation costs.


The last major expenditure for American households is food. Everyone has got to eat, right? Spending on food increased by 2.5% last year and was calculated by both foods consumed at home and outside the home.

In 2018, the average household spent $7,923 on their food.

Why You Won’t Want to Bust Your Budget

Making a budget from scratch is the easy part. Sticking to it is difficult. However, when you keep to your budget you will start to see the benefit almost immediately.

Here are some of the major drawbacks of breaking your budget:


When you don’t stick your budget, you will overspend. You are more likely to use loans or expensive credit cards to satisfy your spending habits.

Accumulating debt creates financial stress and makes budgeting more difficult. Debt might feel free while you’re swiping those cards, but it incurs interest, which in turn means your finances worsen faster.

Unable to do the things you want

If you create a budget, you don’t have to miss out on exciting events. Budgeting does not mean you stay cooped up at home counting your pennies.

Using a budget, you can pre-plan for additional expenditures outside of your necessities. For example, as Christmas approaches you might budget a little extra to buy a loved one a nice gift or to go out for a Christmas meal with friends. (Tip: the best budgeters know how to get free gift cards!).

free gift cards

However, if you don’t budget and are tempted by impulse buys, when the important things come around you will have no money left for them.


We’ve all been there – about to pay for our weekly groceries when our card is declined at the cashier. It’s a mortifying moment. Maybe you have a credit card you can put the charge on or maybe you don’t, and you must put everything back. Either way, this is embarrassing and feels like you have a big red sign above your head saying ‘broke’.

When budgeting, you are always aware of how your finances stand. This helps you avoid these uncomfortable moments.


A survey by Northwestern Mutual found that money was the biggest cause of stress among Americans, with 44% of people citing it as their most dominant stress. Setting a budget can help you avoid this stress. You will understand your finances and always know where your money is going. Budgeting can also help you save and ensure you have a cash reserve for financial emergencies.

Why Is Budgeting Difficult?

Budgeting can be difficult. We have all been guilty of saying we will cut back on our spending, only to break that promise. This can be for many reasons.

Often, we set unrealistic expectations for ourselves. By not being able to stick to these expectations you then feel like a failure and give up altogether.

Another common reason is not having a goal. Think about why you want to budget. Are you trying to get out of debt? Do you wish to save for something special? Having a goal keeps you motivated and helps you to track your progress toward financial success.

What Are Your Payment Options for Budgeting?

There are several options for budgeting, including cash, direct debit, and credit cards.


With a cash budget, you only make purchases with cash rather than with card or transfers.



  • Prevents overspending. Once your money is gone, it’s gone, and you have no credit.
  • No additional costs for late payment.
  • It is difficult to track spending with cash. You will have to keep your own record rather than checking bank or card statements.
  • Unexpected expenses will be difficult to pay for.

Direct Debit/ACH

You are probably familiar with direct debits because this is likely how you pay your mortgage or utility bills.



  • Make payments online
  • Authorize recurring payments (helpful for things like utility bills and credit card bills)
  • Helpful if you are someone who forgets to pay their bills


  • You may forget you have payments coming out
  • Can end up paying overdraft fees if you don’t have enough in your account to cover charges

Credit Cards

Credit cards give you a temporary loan from your bank. Usually, if you pay these back within 30 days of your statement date you can do so without paying interest.



  • Most credit cards come with online or written statements that make it easy to track expenses
  • Some credit cards offer rewards
  • Can pay for emergency expenses
  • It is possible to spend more than you can pay off
  • If you do not pay off the balance in one cycle you will start accruing interest

Credit Cards That Pay You to Budget

Some credit cards, such as the Discover card, offer rewards with spending. If you can stick to your budget and pay off the balance of your card every cycle, a rewards card gives you an extra boost when trying to budget.

For example, the Discover card offers cashback on spending. This way you get a little something extra back on your everyday costs. Each time you spend you gain a cashback, which accumulates on your cashback balance. Simply reclaim the cash when you desire.

Discover offers a variety of cards with different rewards so you can pick one that best suits your needs:

  • Discover it® Cash Back: You get 5% cashback on up to $1,500 each quarter
  • Discover it® Chrome: You get 2% cashback at gas stations and restaurants on up to $1,000 each quarter
  • Discover it® Miles: 1.5 miles for every dollar you spend, on all purchases

Credit cards are a clear winner when it comes to making payments with your budget:

  • Your spending habits are easier to track, because they are detailed on your statements
  • Providing you pay off your balance in full when it is due, you won’t incur interest
  • You can earn cashback or rewards, giving your finances an extra boost

Yes, it makes sense to budget using credit cards. However, you must be disciplined. You need to create your budget, stick to it, and pay off your card before it starts charging interest.

According to consumerfinance.gov, around 39% of credit cardholders in America pay off their credit cards each month. If you can be like these, then a credit card might be a great option to help you get your finances back on track.

Creating a Budget with a Credit Card

We’ve established that credit cards can be helpful when budgeting. But is not often that you hear the words ‘credit card’ and ‘budget’ in the same sentence. For your credit cards to be helpful, you need a working budget in place. Here are some top budgeting systems you can use with your credit card:

  • 50/30/20: This is a common budgeting plan where you set aside: 50% of your income for your essentials like rent, food and transport; 30% for wants; and 20% for savings.
  • Zero-sum: Use last month’s income to budget this month’s expenses.
  • Spreadsheet: Create a spreadsheet with two columns: one for your expected expenses and one for your actual expenses. This helps you establish where you are overspending.
  • Online software: There are several online budgeting software programs available. Personal Capital is a great example. They have several free tools aimed at helping you manage your personal finances, and some are also available as mobile apps, letting you know what’s happening with your money in real time on your smart phone.

7-step budget building with a credit card:

  1. List expenses
  2. Compare to income
  3. Cut overspend
  4. Create budget categories
  5. Use cards that are best for your spending
  6. Check-in regularly and pay off at least 2x each month
  7. Review at month’s end and start a fresh

Budgeting to Achieve Your Financial Goals

Budgeting is a critical skill for effective money management, which in turn is critical to achieve your financial goals. Therefore, it makes sense to develop a budgeting strategy based upon your financial goals. Thus, we recommend you follow these seven budgeting steps:

  • Step #1: Set your financial goals
  • Step #2: Predict your income based upon your last six months’ income
  • Step #3: Predict your expenses (necessary and discretionary) based upon the last six months’ expenses
  • Step #4: Calculate your savings rates (minimum savings rate is income minus all spending, maximum is income minus necessary spending)
  • Step #5: Evaluate your financial goals against your spending
  • Step #6: Track your savings every month
  • Step #7: Track your net wealth regularly to monitor progress toward your financial goals

Which Payment Type Can Help You stick to a Budget? Credit Cards.

Sticking to a budget can be tough. In today’s world, with so many online payment options we can often feel detached from our spending and start accumulating debt quickly. However, if you examine your finances and put a realistic budget in place, budgeting with credit cards can be one of the best options available to you.

Use credit cards that earn the best rewards for you and get a little something extra back when you make purchases. But also make a budget and ensure you keep your spending in check. You can use online calculators to work out how much you should be spending in each category (rent, food, clothing, etc.) each month.

The content on dollarbreak.com is for informational and educational purposes only and cannot replace any professional financial advice.
Conduct your own research and seek the advice of a licensed financial advisor. Please read the full Terms of use and Privacy Policy.