DollarBreak is reader-supported, when you sign up through links on this post, we may receive compensation. Disclosure.
The content is for informational purposes only. Conduct your own research and seek advice of a licensed financial advisor. Terms.
Which is Better for Selling the Car?
Selling your car to Vroom and Carvana are similar in many ways. Both platforms enable you to get a quote for your used vehicle by submitting an online form and pick up your vehicle from your driveway for free.
However, there are some differences that may help you decide which company to sell your car to.
Overall, Carvana wins over Vroom in multiple ways. While it offers a free pickup, Carvana also lets you pick the option to meet the Carvana representative yourself and drop off your vehicle. The Carvana rep will hand you the check on the spot, while Vroom’s check may take up to three days to arrive in your mailbox. Alternatively, you can also choose to get your payment via direct deposit or direct debit.
Pro tip: Offers depend on the car and its condition. So request a quote from Vroom and Carvana to accept the best deal.
Vroom vs. Carvana Comparison
|Cars accepted||Drivable condition||In good condition, 1992+|
|Requesting quotes||Online application||Online application|
|Offer validity||7 days or an additional 250 miles||7 days or an additional 1,000 miles|
|Payments offered||Cash or trade-in value||Cash or trade-in value|
|Payout||Mailed check||Check, direct deposit, direct debit|
|Car pickup||Free pickup||Free pickup or dropoff|
|Physical locations||Only in Texas||33 Car Vending Machines|
|Turnaround time||Up to 72 hours||Up to 72 hours|
|Customer service||Phone, email||Phone, email, online form|
Vroom accepts used cars in drivable condition while Carvana has additional requirements:
- The car must have a working odometer
- Pass a safe test drive
- They buy cars that are manufactured after 1992.
Neither Vroom, nor Carvana charges any fees. Both companies provide a quote for free and offer a free pickup.
Both Vroom and Carvana offer free instant quotes after you submit an online application form.
Information you’ll need to include in Vroom application:
- Make and model of your car
- Year of manufacturing
- VIN code
- Current condition
Information you’ll need to include in Carvana application:
- Make and model
- Year of manufacturing
- VIN code
- Loan status
- Mechanical issues
- Accident history
- Premium features
- General condition
Vroom’s offer is valid for 7 days or an additional 250 miles. With Carvana, your offer is valid for 7 days or for an additional 1,000 miles.
If you sell your car to Vroom, the company will mail you a check the same day they pick up your car. Meanwhile, the Carvana agent will hand you the check on the spot.
Additionally, Carvana offers direct deposit and direct debit payment options as well.
Alternatively, both Vroom and Carvana offer a trade-in option and bring your new car on your scheduled pickup date.
Since Carvana hands you the check on the spot or sends you a direct deposit, it means you’ll get paid immediately. On the other hand, Vroom will send you the check by mail. While Vroom sends checks immediately after a pickup, it may take two to three days to arrive in your mailbox.
However, note that it may take up to 7 days for checks to clear.
Both Vroom and Carvana offer a free pickup.
It’s noteworthy that Vroom collects cars from 48 states.
Vroom and Carvana representatives will also do a quick inspection to make sure that the car’s condition matches the details you’ve submitted in your application. If everything checks, you’ll get the agreed-upon amount for your vehicle. If there’s something that doesn’t match your description, the companies may change the offer.
Since both Vroom and Carvana only accept accident-free cars, your offer may get rejected if the inspector finds the proof of accident.
If you wish to deliver your car to Vroom’s physical location by yourself, you can visit it in Texas. You can use the TexasDirectAuto website to find the Vroom location near you.
On the other hand, Carvana has 33 Carvana Vending Machines nationwide. These are the places where you can drop off your vehicle and pick up a new one.
Both companies, Vroom and Carvana, promise a fast turnaround. It typically takes up to 72 hours to sell your car to either company.
Vroom customer service is accessible through:
- Phone: 855-534-1300
- Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Carvana enables you to contact customer service by phone: 800-333-4554.
On Trustpilot, Vroom reviews score 1.3 while the overall Carvana review score is 2.8. On BBB, Vroom has a customer review rating of 1.12. Meanwhile, the BBB rates Vroom with F and hasn’t issued an accreditation. Carvana doesn’t have any ratings on the BBB.
Vroom customers praised the straightforward selling process of selling their cars. Meanwhile, Vroom complaints come from car buyers. They reported issues like receiving cars with technical and physical issues.
Carvana customers mostly note that they’re happy they got great deals from the company and could sell their car quickly. On the other hand, some complained that the selling process isn’t as hassle-free as the company claims.
Vroom & Carvana Alternatives
Similar to Vroom and Carvana, Peddle also provides you with an instant quote after you submit an online application form through its website. After getting an offer, you’ll have 7 days to consider the offer and if you accept it, the Peddle representative will pick up (or tow) your car for free.
Like Carvana, Peddle will also hand you the check right on your driveway.
Wheelzy is another reputable alternative to Vroom and Carvana that operates nationwide. Unlike Vroom, but similar to Carvana, Wheelzy uses AI (artificial intelligence) to provide an estimated value of your car using the information you submit using an online form.
Unlike Vroom and Carvana, Wheelzy accepts cars that are damaged or even junk. If you accept the Wheelzy offer, the representative will either pick up your car or tow it from your driveway depending on its condition.